UK researcher: EFSA voodoo lily weight loss approval is “strange”

By Shane Starling

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags: Weight loss, Nutrition, European food safety authority

Konjac: Is there a little voodoo in EFSA's positive weight loss opinion?
Konjac: Is there a little voodoo in EFSA's positive weight loss opinion?
A leading UK nutritionist says a 2010 European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) approval of a weight loss health claim for the Asian botanical, konjac mannan, defies the clinical data assessed.

As part of an investigation into weight loss/satiety claims, Carrie Ruxton, PhD, RD, performed an audit of the opinion and found only four of nine studies in the article 13 general function opinion showed positive weight loss results.

She said the evidence for konjac (Amorphophallus konjac)​, also known as glucomannan or voodoo lily or devil’s tongue, did not support, “EFSA’s statement that ‘most’ of the studies found a statistically significant effect.”

“The amount of weight loss achieved by adding glucomannan to the diet is also unremarkable. I would question why EFSA allowed glucomannan a weight loss claim given the balance of evidence, particularly when they have been so hard on other foods/substances. It's a strange decision.”

The opinion

In the opinion​, aimed at overweight adults, EFSA’s Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies (NDA) found, “…most of the intervention studies, which were of adequate sample size and duration, found a statistically significant effect of glucomannan on body weight loss in the context of a hypocaloric diet when administered as a pre-load before meals, and that the mechanism by which glucomannan could exert the claimed effect is established.”

The NDA said the claim was valid when at least 3g of glucomannan is consumed daily in three doses of at least 1g each, with 1-2 glasses of water before meals, in the context of an energy-restricted diet.

Ruxton said she was surprised by the opinion given the only two other approved weight loss claims were for calorie-restricted foods which were ‘no brainers’.

“Glucomannan is supposed to be taken in capsule form before meals as part of a calorie-controlled diet,”​ she said.

“To me, that looks more like a ‘herbal’ medicine than a food.”

Positive possibilities

Elise Aubin,​a health claim and food safety expert at French consultancy, Nutraveris, agreed the majority of evidence in the konjac file was negative, but noted, “it seems EFSA has favoured longer studies and most of them are positive.”

She said one study (Keithley and Swanson (2005)) had demonstrated mechanism of action which had also been influential and provided added, evidence of efficacy.”

Moreover, konjac has been studied in a lot of Japanese trials for its effects and it is authorised as functional food for years,”​ she said, while adding, It is still paradoxical because the evidence doesn’t show clearly a health benefit.”

Related topics: Nutrition, All Asia-Pacific, Supplements

Related news

Related products

show more

Pycnogenol® Reduces Severity of Dry Mouth

Pycnogenol® Reduces Severity of Dry Mouth

Horphag Research | 15-Jun-2020 | Clinical Study

Newly published research shows daily supplementation with Pycnogenol® significantly reduced mouth dryness by 66% and demonstrated 82% improvement of saliva...

Pycnogenol® Provides Benefits for Men Managing ED

Pycnogenol® Provides Benefits for Men Managing ED

Horphag Research | 30-Mar-2020 | Clinical Study

Newly published research shows daily supplementation with Pycnogenol® can strengthen erectile function and address common conditions related to type 2...

Gain profits and sustainability in food production

Gain profits and sustainability in food production

Dassault Systems Ltd | 06-Sep-2017 | Technical / White Paper

The challenge of feeding the world is forcing food producers to stretch their supply chains across continents, which comes at the expense of resources...

Related suppliers

Follow us

Products

View more

Webinars

Food & Beverage Trailblazers

F&B Trailblazers Podcast